Games for every day Joes and Janes, all day, like it's your job. Updated every Mon - Wed - Fri
Published on November 3, 2008 By DorkCoffeez In Gaming

Who at GenCon hates angels?

Gary Gygax, the co-founder of Dungeons and Dragons, held the Christan's Children's Fund to be his favorite charity cause. Even if you are not familiar with this charity you likely have seen the commercials with Pernell Roberts (looks like the real life Henry Jones from The Last Crusade) explaining to you how the children are starving and you can sponsor them.

At this year's GenCon a charity auction raised $17,000 for the charity in Gygax name (whom passed away this last March 4th of an aneurysm). The CCF turned the money down due to the fact the money was partly raised by the sales of  Dungeons and Dragons materials. Now while I support the freedom to have the right to turn down money provided in such a way I feel that the CCF had the responsibility to put that aside in the economic climate currently at hand. Instead they refused with out much comment on the matter. Could they honestly believe that a large group of gamers whom are attempting to give them free money to their cause have only the worst in mind for them? Or that the agreement on the principals of both groups to feed the needy does not over shadow the public view of popular games and the people that they might associate with?

I understand that a charity must be very strict on where the money comes from, and whom should get a tax break and so forth. However I belive those laws are in place to handle illegal funding and not a matter of opinion on the group orginization it self. Perhaps if you were a minority schoolastic group and the KKK wanted to donate money I could see why you would refuse their mockery of assistance based on belifes. However since Gygax made many donations to CCF over the years I cannot fathom that suddenly now gamers at large are seen as evil. This is certainly not been the case from whom took the donations previous to this.

Hypocrisy rears it's head, roll to save.

I'm insulted on the behalf of GenCon and I am happy to report that there are less near-sighted groups at work in the world. GenCon gave the money to Fisher House Foundation (http://www.fisherhouse.org/) and so have I thanks to this latest act of elitism.

Seabass


Comments
on Nov 03, 2008

I thought this debate was resolved in 1982.  Dungeons and Dragons is not inherently demonic or anti-Christian.  No more so than your average sci-fi or fantasy novel. 

In junior high school, I remember being persecuted by a Christian friend who staged an "intervention" for me, thinking I was addicted to gaming and couldn't go without D&D for a month.  I gladly surrendered my books, manuals, and dice for that month and happily proved her wrong.  I should've bet her money and donated it to CCF.  Ironically enough, I recently reconnected with her through Facebook and discovered she's completely athiestic and I have become a baptized, active Mormon. Go fig.

Anyway, back on topic: looks like CCF is rejecting perfectly good money. 

on Nov 03, 2008

I understand that a charity must be very strict on where the money comes from, and whom should get a tax break and so forth.

I know you need a receipt and an org needs proper registration if you want a tax deduction, but aren't there still plenty of anonymous donors? IMO, it is more charitable to give anonymously--you leave both your ego and your wallet out of the equation.

And halfway back to topic, for some of us serious RPG fans, D&D money is evil money for entirely different reasons. Gygax was a greed-head who polluted a genre that should be open-source based with an endless chain of commercial hack jobs aimed at getting people addicted to shopping for accessories instead of using the core rules as a springboard for creating their own worlds. And then he sold the brand to a crowd with even worse values.

Ranting aside, it does seem both un-Christian and bottom-line stupid for CCF to treat the gaming crowd like Larry Flynt or Madalyn Murray O'Hair.

on Nov 03, 2008

I don't know if this was intentional but I really like the irony of the GenCon picture having an angel in it when it is the CCF we are talking about.

on Nov 03, 2008

Gygax was a greed-head who polluted a genre that should be open-source based with an endless chain of commercial hack jobs aimed at getting people addicted to shopping for accessories instead of using the core rules as a springboard for creating their own worlds. And then he sold the brand to a crowd with even worse values.

Salute! Breaks the heart doesn't it?

@Seabass... I dunno, I kind of get it personally. I mean if Christianity doesn't have idealism...what does it have? I can understand that they're not interested in taking money from people who cultivate heretical practise in the minds of potential converts. I mean it's counter-productive in the long run isn't it?

Besides, this was a perfectly good opportunity to publicize the fact that they're taking a stand against something, and as far as I can tell...that's precisely the business of religon. It's kind of like pick-pocketing at a dog-fight or something, except the dogs are imaginary.

on Nov 03, 2008

Forget the whole christian/non-christian thing. Fact is they are a charity to help people, that should be first and foremost. If some that need help are now turned away due to their closemindedness, then who is really the bad guy there?

on Nov 03, 2008

You mean Christians are behaving like idiots?  Frankly I'm shocked...and obviously full of sarcasm.

~Zoo

on Nov 03, 2008

I'm not surprized to see a christian charity acting this way.

on Nov 04, 2008

I thought this debate was resolved in 1982.

Not everybody was convinced back then. Those who were not convinced back then are unlikely to be convinced today. The logic never was totally air-tight for either side.

 

on Nov 04, 2008

Not everybody was convinced back then. Those who were not convinced back then are unlikely to be convinced today. The logic never was totally air-tight for either side.

What's logic got to do with it. Either you take someone's word ("We're not satanic. It's just a game.") or you don't. It is a matter of trust, which can be very difficult for parties with extremely different world views.

BTW, a portion of the D&D Is Evil crowd also have a list of SF authors who should be banned/burned/etc. Lots of the hard science crowd are openly atheistic, and plenty of others portray sexuality and family patterns that are anathema in some churches. If I wanted to start earning money on the ex-gay talk circuit, I could do a long riff on how Robert Heinlein made me gay. (He didn't; he actually left me thinking I was bisexual until I fell in love with a young woman and she still tasted funny.)

on Nov 04, 2008

GW Swicord
If I wanted to start earning money on the ex-gay talk circuit, I could do a long riff on how Robert Heinlein made me gay. (He didn't; he actually left me thinking I was bisexual until I fell in love with a young woman and she still tasted funny.)

This is either WAY TMI or the start of your next (and probably first) bestseller.

I'm just not sure which at the moment.